Facial Trustworthiness Predicts Extreme Criminal-Sentencing Outcomes

John Paul Wilson, Nicholas O. Rule

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

76 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Untrustworthy faces incur negative judgments across numerous domains. Existing work in this area has focused on situations in which the target’s trustworthiness is relevant to the judgment (e.g., criminal verdicts and economic games). Yet in the present studies, we found that people also overgeneralized trustworthiness in criminal-sentencing decisions when trustworthiness should not be judicially relevant, and they did so even for the most extreme sentencing decision: condemning someone to death. In Study 1, we found that perceptions of untrustworthiness predicted death sentences (vs. life sentences) for convicted murderers in Florida (N = 742). Moreover, in Study 2, we found that the link between trustworthiness and the death sentence occurred even when participants viewed innocent people who had been exonerated after originally being sentenced to death. These results highlight the power of facial appearance to prejudice perceivers and affect life outcomes even to the point of execution, which suggests an alarming bias in the criminal-justice system.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1325-1331
Number of pages7
JournalPsychological Science
Volume26
Issue number8
DOIs
StatePublished - 7 Aug 2015

Fingerprint

Criminal Law
Economics
Power (Psychology)

Keywords

  • face perception
  • judgment
  • legal processes
  • open data
  • open materials
  • physical appearance
  • social perception

Cite this

@article{94c83a07d6cd4e71b83abd712e8a1bf8,
title = "Facial Trustworthiness Predicts Extreme Criminal-Sentencing Outcomes",
abstract = "Untrustworthy faces incur negative judgments across numerous domains. Existing work in this area has focused on situations in which the target’s trustworthiness is relevant to the judgment (e.g., criminal verdicts and economic games). Yet in the present studies, we found that people also overgeneralized trustworthiness in criminal-sentencing decisions when trustworthiness should not be judicially relevant, and they did so even for the most extreme sentencing decision: condemning someone to death. In Study 1, we found that perceptions of untrustworthiness predicted death sentences (vs. life sentences) for convicted murderers in Florida (N = 742). Moreover, in Study 2, we found that the link between trustworthiness and the death sentence occurred even when participants viewed innocent people who had been exonerated after originally being sentenced to death. These results highlight the power of facial appearance to prejudice perceivers and affect life outcomes even to the point of execution, which suggests an alarming bias in the criminal-justice system.",
keywords = "face perception, judgment, legal processes, open data, open materials, physical appearance, social perception",
author = "Wilson, {John Paul} and Rule, {Nicholas O.}",
year = "2015",
month = "8",
day = "7",
doi = "10.1177/0956797615590992",
language = "English",
volume = "26",
pages = "1325--1331",
journal = "Psychological Science",
issn = "0956-7976",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Inc.",
number = "8",

}

Facial Trustworthiness Predicts Extreme Criminal-Sentencing Outcomes. / Wilson, John Paul; Rule, Nicholas O.

In: Psychological Science, Vol. 26, No. 8, 07.08.2015, p. 1325-1331.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Facial Trustworthiness Predicts Extreme Criminal-Sentencing Outcomes

AU - Wilson, John Paul

AU - Rule, Nicholas O.

PY - 2015/8/7

Y1 - 2015/8/7

N2 - Untrustworthy faces incur negative judgments across numerous domains. Existing work in this area has focused on situations in which the target’s trustworthiness is relevant to the judgment (e.g., criminal verdicts and economic games). Yet in the present studies, we found that people also overgeneralized trustworthiness in criminal-sentencing decisions when trustworthiness should not be judicially relevant, and they did so even for the most extreme sentencing decision: condemning someone to death. In Study 1, we found that perceptions of untrustworthiness predicted death sentences (vs. life sentences) for convicted murderers in Florida (N = 742). Moreover, in Study 2, we found that the link between trustworthiness and the death sentence occurred even when participants viewed innocent people who had been exonerated after originally being sentenced to death. These results highlight the power of facial appearance to prejudice perceivers and affect life outcomes even to the point of execution, which suggests an alarming bias in the criminal-justice system.

AB - Untrustworthy faces incur negative judgments across numerous domains. Existing work in this area has focused on situations in which the target’s trustworthiness is relevant to the judgment (e.g., criminal verdicts and economic games). Yet in the present studies, we found that people also overgeneralized trustworthiness in criminal-sentencing decisions when trustworthiness should not be judicially relevant, and they did so even for the most extreme sentencing decision: condemning someone to death. In Study 1, we found that perceptions of untrustworthiness predicted death sentences (vs. life sentences) for convicted murderers in Florida (N = 742). Moreover, in Study 2, we found that the link between trustworthiness and the death sentence occurred even when participants viewed innocent people who had been exonerated after originally being sentenced to death. These results highlight the power of facial appearance to prejudice perceivers and affect life outcomes even to the point of execution, which suggests an alarming bias in the criminal-justice system.

KW - face perception

KW - judgment

KW - legal processes

KW - open data

KW - open materials

KW - physical appearance

KW - social perception

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84938632543&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1177/0956797615590992

DO - 10.1177/0956797615590992

M3 - Article

C2 - 26162847

AN - SCOPUS:84938632543

VL - 26

SP - 1325

EP - 1331

JO - Psychological Science

JF - Psychological Science

SN - 0956-7976

IS - 8

ER -