TY - JOUR
T1 - Nine Key Factors in Extended Litigation-Based Reform of State Child Welfare Agencies
AU - Alvarez, Ariel
PY - 2020/9
Y1 - 2020/9
N2 - Youth entering foster care encounter a multi-system state child welfare agency (CWA) that provides foster care and other child welfare related functions. CWAs face complex and ongoing governmental and organizational challenges contributing to a history of serious systemic deficiencies due to chronic under-funding, under-staffing, and under-resourcing. Child welfare advocates employ class-action litigation to engage leaders in sustained focus and action to remedy systemic failures and hold them accountable for poor care and outcomes for youth in foster care. A qualitative design using multiple case study and document analysis methods was used to explore extended litigation-based reform of thirteen state CWAs to identify key factors that contributed to substantive improvements in the state foster care system. Nine dominant factors were identified that included: (a) well-defined consent decrees and settlement agreements; (b) court-appointed monitors, special masters, and receiverships; (c) moving from an adversarial to collaborative environment; (d) case practice model/principles-based reform plan and family/team-based case management; (e) executive leadership support, resistance, and turnover (f) state governmental and legislature support; (g) building institutional capacity; (h) CWA structured as an independent agency; and (i) incremental reform plan implementation.
AB - Youth entering foster care encounter a multi-system state child welfare agency (CWA) that provides foster care and other child welfare related functions. CWAs face complex and ongoing governmental and organizational challenges contributing to a history of serious systemic deficiencies due to chronic under-funding, under-staffing, and under-resourcing. Child welfare advocates employ class-action litigation to engage leaders in sustained focus and action to remedy systemic failures and hold them accountable for poor care and outcomes for youth in foster care. A qualitative design using multiple case study and document analysis methods was used to explore extended litigation-based reform of thirteen state CWAs to identify key factors that contributed to substantive improvements in the state foster care system. Nine dominant factors were identified that included: (a) well-defined consent decrees and settlement agreements; (b) court-appointed monitors, special masters, and receiverships; (c) moving from an adversarial to collaborative environment; (d) case practice model/principles-based reform plan and family/team-based case management; (e) executive leadership support, resistance, and turnover (f) state governmental and legislature support; (g) building institutional capacity; (h) CWA structured as an independent agency; and (i) incremental reform plan implementation.
KW - Case Study
KW - Child Welfare Litigation
KW - Foster Care
KW - Reform
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85086118340&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1016/j.childyouth.2020.105115
DO - 10.1016/j.childyouth.2020.105115
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:85086118340
SN - 0190-7409
VL - 116
JO - Children and Youth Services Review
JF - Children and Youth Services Review
M1 - 105115
ER -