Traitor in our midst: Cultural variations in Japanese vs. Oklahoman public discourse on domestic terrorism in the spring of 1995

Carl W. Roberts, Yong Wang

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

3 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

When "one of our own" commits mass murder, mechanisms that sustain our social order are opened to question. Based on two samples of newspaper editorials written in 1995 - either after the poison gas attack in the Tokyo subway or after the Oklahoma City bombing - evidence is provided that Japanese editorialists advised strategies for retaining order, whereas Oklahoman authors endorsed ones for reestablishing it. In accordance with Simmel's distinction between faithfulness and gratitude as social forms, Japanese advised faithful continuation of wholesome interactions with their terrorists, whereas Oklahomans expressed gratitude for rescue workers' assistance. We apply modality analysis to identify those specific activities that authors presume their readers to accept as inevitable, possible, impossible, or contingent for each other. Working from this modal rhetoric in the two public discourses, we build more comprehensive inferences regarding the underlying logics of Japanese faithfulness versus Oklahoman gratitude - logics that reflect the respective motivational dynamics underlying extant theories of identity and exchange.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)463-494
Number of pages32
JournalComparative Sociology
Volume9
Issue number4
DOIs
StatePublished - 1 May 2010

Fingerprint

mass murder
social order
terrorism
newspaper
rhetoric
assistance
worker
discourse
interaction
evidence

Keywords

  • Culture
  • Discourse
  • Modality
  • Simmel
  • Terrorism
  • text analysis

Cite this

@article{828ce2292184426db8f764770857b24c,
title = "Traitor in our midst: Cultural variations in Japanese vs. Oklahoman public discourse on domestic terrorism in the spring of 1995",
abstract = "When {"}one of our own{"} commits mass murder, mechanisms that sustain our social order are opened to question. Based on two samples of newspaper editorials written in 1995 - either after the poison gas attack in the Tokyo subway or after the Oklahoma City bombing - evidence is provided that Japanese editorialists advised strategies for retaining order, whereas Oklahoman authors endorsed ones for reestablishing it. In accordance with Simmel's distinction between faithfulness and gratitude as social forms, Japanese advised faithful continuation of wholesome interactions with their terrorists, whereas Oklahomans expressed gratitude for rescue workers' assistance. We apply modality analysis to identify those specific activities that authors presume their readers to accept as inevitable, possible, impossible, or contingent for each other. Working from this modal rhetoric in the two public discourses, we build more comprehensive inferences regarding the underlying logics of Japanese faithfulness versus Oklahoman gratitude - logics that reflect the respective motivational dynamics underlying extant theories of identity and exchange.",
keywords = "Culture, Discourse, Modality, Simmel, Terrorism, text analysis",
author = "Roberts, {Carl W.} and Yong Wang",
year = "2010",
month = "5",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1163/156913210X12530678932808",
language = "English",
volume = "9",
pages = "463--494",
journal = "Comparative Sociology",
issn = "1569-1322",
publisher = "Brill Academic Publishers",
number = "4",

}

Traitor in our midst : Cultural variations in Japanese vs. Oklahoman public discourse on domestic terrorism in the spring of 1995. / Roberts, Carl W.; Wang, Yong.

In: Comparative Sociology, Vol. 9, No. 4, 01.05.2010, p. 463-494.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Traitor in our midst

T2 - Cultural variations in Japanese vs. Oklahoman public discourse on domestic terrorism in the spring of 1995

AU - Roberts, Carl W.

AU - Wang, Yong

PY - 2010/5/1

Y1 - 2010/5/1

N2 - When "one of our own" commits mass murder, mechanisms that sustain our social order are opened to question. Based on two samples of newspaper editorials written in 1995 - either after the poison gas attack in the Tokyo subway or after the Oklahoma City bombing - evidence is provided that Japanese editorialists advised strategies for retaining order, whereas Oklahoman authors endorsed ones for reestablishing it. In accordance with Simmel's distinction between faithfulness and gratitude as social forms, Japanese advised faithful continuation of wholesome interactions with their terrorists, whereas Oklahomans expressed gratitude for rescue workers' assistance. We apply modality analysis to identify those specific activities that authors presume their readers to accept as inevitable, possible, impossible, or contingent for each other. Working from this modal rhetoric in the two public discourses, we build more comprehensive inferences regarding the underlying logics of Japanese faithfulness versus Oklahoman gratitude - logics that reflect the respective motivational dynamics underlying extant theories of identity and exchange.

AB - When "one of our own" commits mass murder, mechanisms that sustain our social order are opened to question. Based on two samples of newspaper editorials written in 1995 - either after the poison gas attack in the Tokyo subway or after the Oklahoma City bombing - evidence is provided that Japanese editorialists advised strategies for retaining order, whereas Oklahoman authors endorsed ones for reestablishing it. In accordance with Simmel's distinction between faithfulness and gratitude as social forms, Japanese advised faithful continuation of wholesome interactions with their terrorists, whereas Oklahomans expressed gratitude for rescue workers' assistance. We apply modality analysis to identify those specific activities that authors presume their readers to accept as inevitable, possible, impossible, or contingent for each other. Working from this modal rhetoric in the two public discourses, we build more comprehensive inferences regarding the underlying logics of Japanese faithfulness versus Oklahoman gratitude - logics that reflect the respective motivational dynamics underlying extant theories of identity and exchange.

KW - Culture

KW - Discourse

KW - Modality

KW - Simmel

KW - Terrorism

KW - text analysis

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=77957731752&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1163/156913210X12530678932808

DO - 10.1163/156913210X12530678932808

M3 - Article

AN - SCOPUS:77957731752

VL - 9

SP - 463

EP - 494

JO - Comparative Sociology

JF - Comparative Sociology

SN - 1569-1322

IS - 4

ER -