Waking the undead: Implications of a soft explosive model for the timing of placental mammal diversification

Mark S. Springer, Christopher A. Emerling, Robert W. Meredith, Jan E. Janečka, Eduardo Eizirik, William J. Murphy

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

21 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The explosive, long fuse, and short fuse models represent competing hypotheses for the timing of placental mammal diversification. Support for the explosive model, which posits both interordinal and intraordinal diversification after the KPg mass extinction, derives from morphological cladistic studies that place Cretaceous eutherians outside of crown Placentalia. By contrast, most molecular studies favor the long fuse model wherein interordinal cladogenesis occurred in the Cretaceous followed by intraordinal cladogenesis after the KPg boundary. Phillips (2016) proposed a soft explosive model that allows for the emergence of a few lineages (Xenarthra, Afrotheria, Euarchontoglires, Laurasiatheria) in the Cretaceous, but otherwise agrees with the explosive model in positing the majority of interordinal diversification after the KPg mass extinction. Phillips (2016) argues that rate transference errors associated with large body size and long lifespan have inflated previous estimates of interordinal divergence times, and further suggests that most interordinal divergences are positioned after the KPg boundary when rate transference errors are avoided through the elimination of calibrations in large-bodied and/or long lifespan clades. Here, we show that rate transference errors can also occur in the opposite direction and drag forward estimated divergence dates when calibrations in large-bodied/long lifespan clades are omitted. This dragging forward effect results in the occurrence of more than half a billion years of ‘zombie lineages’ on Phillips’ preferred timetree. By contrast with ghost lineages, which are a logical byproduct of an incomplete fossil record, zombie lineages occur when estimated divergence dates are younger than the minimum age of the oldest crown fossils. We also present the results of new timetree analyses that address the rate transference problem highlighted by Phillips (2016) by deleting taxa that exceed thresholds for body size and lifespan. These analyses recover all interordinal divergence times in the Cretaceous and are consistent with the long fuse model of placental diversification. Finally, we outline potential problems with morphological cladistic analyses of higher-level relationships among placental mammals that may account for the perceived discrepancies between molecular and paleontological estimates of placental divergence times.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)86-102
Number of pages17
JournalMolecular Phylogenetics and Evolution
Volume106
DOIs
StatePublished - 1 Jan 2017

Fingerprint

explosive
Mammals
Genetic Speciation
mammal
divergence
Biological Extinction
mammals
Body Size
Crowns
Calibration
Cretaceous
Xenarthra
mass extinction
cladistics
body size
calibration
extinction
fossils
phylogeny
fossil record

Keywords

  • Divergence time
  • Ghost lineage
  • Long fuse model
  • Placental mammal
  • Zombie lineage

Cite this

Springer, Mark S. ; Emerling, Christopher A. ; Meredith, Robert W. ; Janečka, Jan E. ; Eizirik, Eduardo ; Murphy, William J. / Waking the undead : Implications of a soft explosive model for the timing of placental mammal diversification. In: Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution. 2017 ; Vol. 106. pp. 86-102.
@article{d5671078413c4f8b978892f35ae3095b,
title = "Waking the undead: Implications of a soft explosive model for the timing of placental mammal diversification",
abstract = "The explosive, long fuse, and short fuse models represent competing hypotheses for the timing of placental mammal diversification. Support for the explosive model, which posits both interordinal and intraordinal diversification after the KPg mass extinction, derives from morphological cladistic studies that place Cretaceous eutherians outside of crown Placentalia. By contrast, most molecular studies favor the long fuse model wherein interordinal cladogenesis occurred in the Cretaceous followed by intraordinal cladogenesis after the KPg boundary. Phillips (2016) proposed a soft explosive model that allows for the emergence of a few lineages (Xenarthra, Afrotheria, Euarchontoglires, Laurasiatheria) in the Cretaceous, but otherwise agrees with the explosive model in positing the majority of interordinal diversification after the KPg mass extinction. Phillips (2016) argues that rate transference errors associated with large body size and long lifespan have inflated previous estimates of interordinal divergence times, and further suggests that most interordinal divergences are positioned after the KPg boundary when rate transference errors are avoided through the elimination of calibrations in large-bodied and/or long lifespan clades. Here, we show that rate transference errors can also occur in the opposite direction and drag forward estimated divergence dates when calibrations in large-bodied/long lifespan clades are omitted. This dragging forward effect results in the occurrence of more than half a billion years of ‘zombie lineages’ on Phillips’ preferred timetree. By contrast with ghost lineages, which are a logical byproduct of an incomplete fossil record, zombie lineages occur when estimated divergence dates are younger than the minimum age of the oldest crown fossils. We also present the results of new timetree analyses that address the rate transference problem highlighted by Phillips (2016) by deleting taxa that exceed thresholds for body size and lifespan. These analyses recover all interordinal divergence times in the Cretaceous and are consistent with the long fuse model of placental diversification. Finally, we outline potential problems with morphological cladistic analyses of higher-level relationships among placental mammals that may account for the perceived discrepancies between molecular and paleontological estimates of placental divergence times.",
keywords = "Divergence time, Ghost lineage, Long fuse model, Placental mammal, Zombie lineage",
author = "Springer, {Mark S.} and Emerling, {Christopher A.} and Meredith, {Robert W.} and Janečka, {Jan E.} and Eduardo Eizirik and Murphy, {William J.}",
year = "2017",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.ympev.2016.09.017",
language = "English",
volume = "106",
pages = "86--102",
journal = "Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution",
issn = "1055-7903",
publisher = "Academic Press Inc.",

}

Waking the undead : Implications of a soft explosive model for the timing of placental mammal diversification. / Springer, Mark S.; Emerling, Christopher A.; Meredith, Robert W.; Janečka, Jan E.; Eizirik, Eduardo; Murphy, William J.

In: Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution, Vol. 106, 01.01.2017, p. 86-102.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Waking the undead

T2 - Implications of a soft explosive model for the timing of placental mammal diversification

AU - Springer, Mark S.

AU - Emerling, Christopher A.

AU - Meredith, Robert W.

AU - Janečka, Jan E.

AU - Eizirik, Eduardo

AU - Murphy, William J.

PY - 2017/1/1

Y1 - 2017/1/1

N2 - The explosive, long fuse, and short fuse models represent competing hypotheses for the timing of placental mammal diversification. Support for the explosive model, which posits both interordinal and intraordinal diversification after the KPg mass extinction, derives from morphological cladistic studies that place Cretaceous eutherians outside of crown Placentalia. By contrast, most molecular studies favor the long fuse model wherein interordinal cladogenesis occurred in the Cretaceous followed by intraordinal cladogenesis after the KPg boundary. Phillips (2016) proposed a soft explosive model that allows for the emergence of a few lineages (Xenarthra, Afrotheria, Euarchontoglires, Laurasiatheria) in the Cretaceous, but otherwise agrees with the explosive model in positing the majority of interordinal diversification after the KPg mass extinction. Phillips (2016) argues that rate transference errors associated with large body size and long lifespan have inflated previous estimates of interordinal divergence times, and further suggests that most interordinal divergences are positioned after the KPg boundary when rate transference errors are avoided through the elimination of calibrations in large-bodied and/or long lifespan clades. Here, we show that rate transference errors can also occur in the opposite direction and drag forward estimated divergence dates when calibrations in large-bodied/long lifespan clades are omitted. This dragging forward effect results in the occurrence of more than half a billion years of ‘zombie lineages’ on Phillips’ preferred timetree. By contrast with ghost lineages, which are a logical byproduct of an incomplete fossil record, zombie lineages occur when estimated divergence dates are younger than the minimum age of the oldest crown fossils. We also present the results of new timetree analyses that address the rate transference problem highlighted by Phillips (2016) by deleting taxa that exceed thresholds for body size and lifespan. These analyses recover all interordinal divergence times in the Cretaceous and are consistent with the long fuse model of placental diversification. Finally, we outline potential problems with morphological cladistic analyses of higher-level relationships among placental mammals that may account for the perceived discrepancies between molecular and paleontological estimates of placental divergence times.

AB - The explosive, long fuse, and short fuse models represent competing hypotheses for the timing of placental mammal diversification. Support for the explosive model, which posits both interordinal and intraordinal diversification after the KPg mass extinction, derives from morphological cladistic studies that place Cretaceous eutherians outside of crown Placentalia. By contrast, most molecular studies favor the long fuse model wherein interordinal cladogenesis occurred in the Cretaceous followed by intraordinal cladogenesis after the KPg boundary. Phillips (2016) proposed a soft explosive model that allows for the emergence of a few lineages (Xenarthra, Afrotheria, Euarchontoglires, Laurasiatheria) in the Cretaceous, but otherwise agrees with the explosive model in positing the majority of interordinal diversification after the KPg mass extinction. Phillips (2016) argues that rate transference errors associated with large body size and long lifespan have inflated previous estimates of interordinal divergence times, and further suggests that most interordinal divergences are positioned after the KPg boundary when rate transference errors are avoided through the elimination of calibrations in large-bodied and/or long lifespan clades. Here, we show that rate transference errors can also occur in the opposite direction and drag forward estimated divergence dates when calibrations in large-bodied/long lifespan clades are omitted. This dragging forward effect results in the occurrence of more than half a billion years of ‘zombie lineages’ on Phillips’ preferred timetree. By contrast with ghost lineages, which are a logical byproduct of an incomplete fossil record, zombie lineages occur when estimated divergence dates are younger than the minimum age of the oldest crown fossils. We also present the results of new timetree analyses that address the rate transference problem highlighted by Phillips (2016) by deleting taxa that exceed thresholds for body size and lifespan. These analyses recover all interordinal divergence times in the Cretaceous and are consistent with the long fuse model of placental diversification. Finally, we outline potential problems with morphological cladistic analyses of higher-level relationships among placental mammals that may account for the perceived discrepancies between molecular and paleontological estimates of placental divergence times.

KW - Divergence time

KW - Ghost lineage

KW - Long fuse model

KW - Placental mammal

KW - Zombie lineage

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84989332470&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.ympev.2016.09.017

DO - 10.1016/j.ympev.2016.09.017

M3 - Article

C2 - 27659724

AN - SCOPUS:84989332470

VL - 106

SP - 86

EP - 102

JO - Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution

JF - Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution

SN - 1055-7903

ER -